A relief veterinarian working the same three shifts a month at your practice for the past two years is, in the eyes of most state labor departments, starting to look less like an independent contractor and more like a part-time employee, and the federal rules that were supposed to settle that question keep changing underneath practices that relied on them. The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) proposed in February 2026 to rescind its 2024 worker classification rule and revive a version of the more contractor-friendly test used from 2021 through 2024, according to a Quarles law firm analysis of the proposal. Whether a relief vet gets a 1099 or a W2 turns on how much control your practice actually has over their work, not on what the contract calls them. The federal reset matters, but it is not the whole picture. A third of U.S. states, California and New Jersey among them, apply their own "ABC test" for worker classification, and that state-level test can override the federal answer entirely regardless of what the DOL decides.
Worth flagging up front: the federal rulemaking covered below is still a proposal, not a final rule. Its comment period closed on April 28, 2026, and the DOL's 2026 rulemaking page still lists it as a proposed rule as of November 2026. The state-level tests and exemptions described are current as of publication but change through legislation and litigation, so verify against current counsel before relying on any single state's status here.
What the Federal Rules Actually Say Right Now
The DOL's 2024 rule required weighing six "economic reality" factors, no single one decisive, to determine whether a relief worker was economically dependent on a practice (employee) or genuinely in business for themselves (contractor). Since May 2025, the Wage and Hour Division has stopped enforcing that rule during investigations and instead relies on the older, more business-friendly 2008 Fact Sheet #13 standard, according to a 2025 analysis from A&O Shearman. The same analysis notes that the 2024 rule still technically governs private lawsuits, even though the agency itself has moved on.
The February 2026 proposal would make that shift permanent. It names two "core factors": the worker's control over the work, and their opportunity for profit or loss through their own initiative or investment. Three other factors (the skill the work requires, how permanent the relationship is, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit) only come into play when the core two point in different directions, according to the DOL's 2026 rulemaking page. The proposal also says a practice's actual day-to-day arrangement counts for more than what a contract says is possible. For a relief veterinarian who sets their own available days, works for multiple practices, and isn't required to use the hiring practice's scheduling system, that shift toward core factors tends to favor contractor status. For one who works a fixed weekly schedule set by the practice and uses only the practice's systems and supplies, it does not.
How the IRS Decides Between a 1099 and a W2
The 1099 and the W2 are tax forms, so the tax side of the question runs on its own test. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) sorts the evidence into three categories under its common-law rules for independent contractors and employees:
- Behavioral control. Does the practice control, or have the right to control, what the relief vet does and how they do it?
- Financial control. Does the practice control the business side of the work, such as how the relief vet is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, and who supplies the tools?
- Type of relationship. Is there a written contract or employee-style benefits, is the relationship expected to continue, and is the work a key part of the practice's business?
No single factor settles it, and the IRS tells businesses to document every factor they weighed. In relief terms, a vet who sets their own rates, works for several practices, and invoices you for each shift fits the 1099 profile. A vet on a fixed schedule you set, paid hourly through your payroll, looks like a W2 employee whatever the agreement says. When a relief vet does land on a 1099, our relief veterinarian tax guide walks through what that means on their side of the ledger.
Why California Treats Veterinarians Differently From Most Contractors
California's Dynamex decision and the AB 5 law that followed it created the ABC test, which presumes any worker is an employee unless the hiring business proves all three of: the worker is free from its control, the work falls outside the business's usual course of work, and the worker independently runs the same kind of business elsewhere. That third condition is nearly impossible for a relief veterinarian embedded in a practice's own patient care to satisfy on its face, which is why California's legislature carved out an exemption for licensed veterinarians (along with physicians, dentists, and a handful of other licensed professions), routing them instead to the older, thirteen-factor Borello test, according to an analysis of the exemption from Wilke Fleury LLP.
That exemption sounds like relief, but it is not a green light. Borello still presumes employee status and still requires a practice to prove otherwise across factors like who supplies equipment, whether the relief vet carries their own liability insurance, and whether they set their own hours across multiple clients.
California offers no bright-line test that clears a relief vet as a contractor just because the paperwork says so.
Where Else Classification Risk Runs High
California is not alone in applying the ABC test, and most ABC-test states do not carve out the same veterinarian exemption California does. Roughly a third of states use some version of the test, according to A&O Shearman's 2025 survey of state developments, and New Jersey's Department of Labor and Workforce Development has moved to formally codify how the burden of proof works under its own ABC test, putting the responsibility for proving contractor status squarely on the hiring business.
Only a handful of ABC-test states carve out a licensed-profession exemption the way California does. In most others, a relief veterinarian who works exclusively within a practice's own patient care is presumed to be an employee from the outset.
What Misclassification Actually Costs a Practice
A relief vet's own preference for contractor status does not protect the practice that engaged them. If a state agency or court finds a worker was misclassified, the practice, not the worker, bears the exposure: back payroll taxes, unpaid overtime for hours the relief vet actually worked, retroactive workers' compensation premiums, and potential liability for benefits the worker would have been entitled to as an employee. None of that liability depends on whether both parties agreed to the 1099 arrangement in writing.
For a multi-location group running relief across several states, that risk compounds: a classification that holds up in a common-law state can fail entirely once the same relief vet crosses into an ABC-test one.
How a Private Relief Network Reduces the Classification Burden
Much of a practice's classification risk comes down to a documentation problem as much as a legal one: managing relief shifts internally without a system that separates true 1099 engagements from de facto scheduled employment makes it harder to show, after the fact, which factors actually applied to a given relief vet. Groove supports both 1099 and W2 relief arrangements in the same system, with timesheets, pay terms, and approval records kept per worker, which gives a practice something concrete to point to if a classification is ever challenged, rather than reconstructing shift history from texts and spreadsheets.
Getting this right shift by shift is hard to do with agency staffing, since the agency, not the practice, usually controls the paperwork. But the harder truth is that classification isn't a decision a practice makes once and files away: a relief vet who starts as an occasional fill-in can drift into de facto employee status simply by picking up the same regular shifts month after month, with no new paperwork ever signed. Revisiting each relief arrangement periodically, not just when it begins, is what actually keeps a practice ahead of a test that keeps moving under it.